The Effect of Aluminum on Neurofibrillary Tangles
Image from http://www.cais.net/adear/tangle.html
Involved in the ongoing debate is the speculation that aluminum somehow affects
neurofibrillary tangles. Initially, the scientific community believed that the high
concentration of aluminum in NFTs was an irreparable event in a dying neuron1. Presently, it is believed that aluminum plays a role in NFT formation by
acting on the tau protein, the major component of NFTs.
Because tau contains multiple phosphorylation sites, aluminum acts as a catalyst for the nonenzymatic covalent shift of the triphosphate group from adenosine triphosphate (ATP) to tau. Aluminum, having a positive charge of three, bonds with three phosphates of ATP, each having a negative charge, because the triphosphates have a higher affinity for aluminum than the adenosine. From there, the phosphates, having a greater affinity for the tau protein than the aluminum, are transferred to the protein, causing its precipitation. When this occurs, the entire triphosphate group is transferred to the protein and results in the aggregation of tau2.
Also, evidence of aluminum induced NFT formation in animals has been provided as support
that aluminum does affect neurofibrillary tangles. In 1965, Klatzo and coworkers reported
that the injections of aluminum salts in the brains of rabbits caused NFT formation3. Later, it was found that in cultured rat neurons, aluminum treatment prompts the
formation of NFTs2. In opposition, Lovell et al. argued that no significant
differences in aluminum levels were found in "NFT-bearing neurons compared with NFT-
free neurons" in AD patients4. In a study performed by M.P. Mattson and
colleagues, data indicated that neuronal damage and an alteration of tau did not occur with
increases in aluminum5. The data collected in this same study indicated
that the collection of aluminum alone in neurons cannot perpetuate NFTs, the tell-tale features of Alzheimers disease5.
1 McLachlan. D.R. "The possible relationship between aluminium and Alzheimersdisease and the mechanisms of cellular pathology." Alzheimers Disease and the Environment. 26 (1991): 42-52. 2 Ghany, M.A. et al. "Aluminum-induced Nonenzymatic Phospho-incorporation into Human Tau and Other Proteins." The Journal of Biological Chemistry. 268 (1993): 11976- 11981. 3 Klatzo. I. et al. "Experimental production of neurofibrillary degeneration: I. Light microscopic observations." Journal Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 24 (1965):187-199. 4 Lovell, M.A. et al. "Laser Microprobe Analysis of Brain Aluminum in Alzheimers Disease." Annals of Neurology. 33 (1993): 36-42. 5 Mattson, M.P. "Comparison of the effects of elevated intracellular aluminum and calcium levels on neuronal survival and tau immunoreactivity." Brain Research. 602 (1993): 21-31.
Jennifer McGilton
|