| |
Materials and Methods
These researchers utilized eighty-two serum samples and thirteen cerebrospinal
fluid samples. An IFA technique, involving a fluorescein-labeled conjugate,
was used to visualize these samples. They were examined by a transmitting
fluorescent microscope with a one-hundred watt mercury lamp. Fluorescence
was then analyzed visually with a qualitative scale, which measured the cytoplasmic
fluorescence. Both positive and negative controls were utilized for each
assay, and each was performed in triplicate. For a specific protocol please
refer to the original paper (Malan et al. 2003).
In order to compare the IFA results to those obtained by ELISA protocols, three
external laboratories were consulted for analysis. These laboratories developed
the reference ranges used in the study. Cross reactivity to other related viruses
was also analyzed through comparison to eighteen positive controls for Saint
Louis Encephalitis (SLE), WNV, and dengue. Statistical analysis of the results
was performed with the use of two by two contingency tables.
Results
There was a ninety-eight percent agreement between the ELISA analysis and the
IFA analysis. Sensitivity was documented to be ninety-six percent, and specificity
was shown to be 100%. IFA was shown to be only slightly less sensitive than
MAC-ELISA testing. The IFA was not sensitive enough to determine the difference
between antibodies to SLE, WNV, and dengue. The authors, however, note that
the test can be used along with other personal information obtained from
the patient in order to determine the particular virus involved in the patient’s
symptoms.
Discussion
Detection of IgM and IgG with the IFA protocol developed by this paper was
shown to be cost effective and nearly as sensitive as MAC-ELISA. The difficulties
of performing the MAC-ELISA protocols were overcome with this IFA method.
The IFA protocol can be performed in laboratories that do not have authorization
to store actual WNV. This assay is also well suited for laboratories that
have limited operational budgets.
|